Friday, 5 February 2010

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge


Leaves Show Looped Networks May Be Better Than Branched

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 08:21 PM PST


Tree branches have inspired efficient transit networks, but a new study finds inspiration in leaves. The curvy, connected leaf veins found in some plants are an efficient way to circumvent damaged areas and channel nutrients, report researchers led by Eleni Katifori of the Rockefeller University in New York City.

sciencenews"It's obvious that if you look at leaves, they have a lot of loops," Katifori says. To find out how the looped networks may be beneficial for the plants, the researchers created a computer model to compare how efficiently different branching patterns could do the job of leaf veins, which move water and nutrients around. "The question we're asking is, what's the best network we can build?" Katifori says.

In the simulations, the looped network performed better than nonlooped ones in several important ways, the team reported Jan. 29 in Physical Review Letters. Damage from hungry insects, cold weather or parasites can interrupt leaves' normal venation patterns. Connected circular veins allowed the flow of water and minerals to circumvent areas where veins were destroyed, the team shows. The looped network also allowed leaves to easily adjust the flow rate of water through veins, which can help leaves conserve water on a hot day, Katifori says.

Loop networks aren't found just in tree leaves. Blood vessels in the retina, structural veins in insect wings and the architecture of certain corals are all based on loops, the researchers write. Understanding the benefits of such networks might lead to more efficient man-made network designs.


Videos: 1) Looped vein network grows around a damaged spot./Eleni Katifori. 2) Straight veins are stopped by a damaged spot./Eleni Katifori.

See Also:

Best View Yet of Pluto Shows Rapidly Changing Surface

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 01:43 PM PST




After more than four years of processing on20 hand-built computers, the bestviews evercaptured of Pluto are now available.

Working from 384 images taken by the Hubble Space Telescope in which the image of Pluto itself was just a few pixels across, astronomer Marc Buie and his team at the Southwest Research Institute stitched together the maps of Pluto you see here.

"It also shows you what I consider to be my best guess for what the true color of Pluto would be if you were puttering around near it in a spacecraft," Buie said in a NASA teleconference.

Pluto has mostly been in the news in recent years for its demotion from planet to dwarf planet and subsequent attempts to get it lumped back in with the bigger, round objects of the solar system.

But astronomer Mike Brown of the California Institute of Technology, aka @PlutoKiller on Twitter, said the question of the classification of the celestial body doesn't merit the attention it's gotten.

"That's really not an interesting question to ask," said Brown, who was not involved with the research. "It's a great place to study."

Specifically, what's fascinating to Brown and Buie is the tremendous amount of change that has been observed on Pluto, particularly between images obtained in 1994 and 2003. Based on the new processing of the photos, there has been more change on Pluto than Earth or Mars.

"You're looking at the surface in the solar system where there are the biggest changes we've ever seen," Brown said.

The color of the surface of Pluto changed so markedly, particularly between 2000 and 2002, thatBuie hasspent years checking and rechecking his work, just to make sure the differences weren't an artifact of faulty equipment or calculations.

"I got that result years ago but it's just so hard to understand and believe that I've been checking everything that I can think of," he said. "I'm still nervous about it. It could be that I've just completely screwed this up, but I can't find where."

One thing that gives him confidence is that one of Pluto's moons, Charon, is also in the image they have of the dwarf planet and its color remained constant as Pluto's changed. That makes it less likely that something went haywire in the instrumentation or processing.

The computing power necessary to turn the pixels of Pluto into the global map seen above as considerable. Buie handwrote all the code in a combination of IDL, a scientific programming language, and C. But when he finished and began to crunch the data, it appeared that it would take decades for the calculations to complete.

So, he took the funding he had and scrapped together 20 computers to do the work in parallel.

"I bought these little shuttle boxes and a processor and memory. I got [the price] down to $450 per computer and I had enough to buy 20 computers and have them all grind," he said. "That's about the cheapest supercomputer you can manage."

Planet or not, Pluto will now provide a lens for studying the rest of the objects in the Kuiper Belt beyond Neptune.

"Even though Pluto is not the biggest one it's the closest one and the best one to study," Brown said, "and to help us interpret all these other things we're seeing in the outer solar system.

pluto_map_hubble

Image and Video: NASA, ESA, and M. Buie (Southwest Research Institute)

See Also:

WiSci 2.0: Alexis Madrigal's Twitter, Google Reader feed, and green tech history research site; Wired Science on Twitter and Facebook.

Dinosaur Fossil Reveals True Feather Colors

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 01:21 PM PST

dinosaur_feathers2

Another week, another colorful feathered dinosaur. Hot on the heels of a recent report identifying pigments in fossilized dino feathers and filaments (SN Online: 1/27/10), a different team of scientists says that it has mapped the full pattern of plumage sported by the oldest known feathered dinosaur.

sciencenewsPaleontologists first described Anchiornis huxleyi, which lived in what is now northeastern China between 151 million and 161 million years ago, in September (SN: 10/24/09, p. 8). Reports of the lithe, peacock-sized dinosaur caused quite a stir, not least because the feathered creature was older than Archaeopteryx, which is considered by many scientists to be the oldest known bird.

Now, analyses of fossil feathers from all parts of A. huxleyi's body — reported online Feb. 4 and in an upcoming Science — provide a detailed look at the dino's color scheme. The new findings also bolster the notion that feathers first evolved for a purpose other than flying, scientists say.

A. huxleyi had black and gray body plumage, the team's investigations suggest. And while the long feathers on the front and side of the creature's crest were gray, those sprouting from the top and back of its head were reddish-brown. Along with reddish-brown spots on its head and neck, A. huxleyi sported white racing stripes on its legs and its winglike forelimbs.

dinosaur_feathers_fossilPaleobiologist Jakob Vinther of Yale University and his colleagues took a microscopic look at fossilized feathers at 29 sites on a specimen of A. huxleyi unearthed early last year. Some analyses focused on the small, simple feathers that covered the creature's body and skull, and others targeted the longer, more complex feathers that adorned its forelimbs, legs and feet. "There was hardly any part of the creature that wasn't feathered," Vinther notes.

Almost all of the feathers the team scrutinized contained well-preserved remnants of pigment-bearing structures called melanosomes. Feathers lacking melanosomes were probably white, the researchers note. By comparing the size, shape, density and arrangement of melanosomes in each fossil feather with those in variously colored feathers of modern birds, the team then sketched out what A. huxleyi looked like. "Using those comparisons, we can reliably predict [the creature's] color and map the whole animal," Vinther says.

The team's analyses "reveal an enormous array of information," says Michael Benton, a paleontologist at the University of Bristol in England. The black-and-white bars on A. huxleyi's forelimbs, as well as its colorful crest, are reminiscent of similar features in modern birds, he adds.

Knowing when color appeared in feathers or filaments may help solve the conundrum of why those structures evolved in the first place, Benton says. After all, he notes, A. huxleyi's feathered forelimbs weren't sufficiently large enough to carry the creature's weight in flight. "What's the function of half a wing?" he asks. The fact that feathers appear in the fossil record long before flight-capable birds suggests that feathers initially served a behavioral function, possibly one related to sending visual signals, and only later began to serve an aerodynamic function.

Philip J. Currie, a paleontologist at the University of Alberta in Edmonton, Canada, agrees: "Ancient creatures didn't just sprout feathers and start flying. The feathers were there for another reason first." Fossils reveal that dinosaurs often had very large eyes and sizable optic lobes in their brains. "Dinosaurs were very visual animals, just like birds are," he adds.

Bold patterns of plumage, such as those seen in A. huxleyi, could have served any of a number of functions, Vinther and his colleagues speculate. Besides communicating to members of its own species — a "come here, cutie" to members of the opposite sex, say, or a "back off" message to rival suitors — a quick flash of boldly colored plumage could startle an attacking predator or flush prey out of hiding, the researchers say.

dinosaur_feathers_fossil2

Images: © 2010 National Geographic

See Also:

Compare Aerial Images of WWII Destruction With Today in Google Earth

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 11:51 AM PST

google_history_warsaw_composite

Aerial imagery of Europe in 1943 that shows the devastation of World War II is now available in Google Earth. Comparing photos such as those above of Warsawbefore the war, mmediately after the war and today really brings to life the incredible destruction and amazing recovery of bombed European cities.

Around three dozen cities have images available from 1943 in Google Earth's historical imagery feature including Lyon, France, Naples, Italy and Stuttgart, Germany, all pictured below. The aerial perspective highlights the extent of the demolition.

One of the most striking sets of photos is of the Warsaw ghetto below in 1935, 1943 and present day. It was the largest ghetto in Europe and hundreds of thousands of Jewish people were deported from there or killed there.

The images above show the same time sequence for Warsaw's Old Town at top and Warsaw University.

Via Google Lat Long Blog

google_history_warsaw_ghetto
Warsaw ghetto 1935, 1943 and present day

google_history_naples
Naples, Italy in 1943 and present day

google_history_stuttgart
Stuttgart, Germany in 1943 and present day

google_history_lyon
Lyon, France in 1943 and present day

Images: Google

See Also:

Follow us on Twitter @betsymason and @wiredscience, and on Facebook.

Athletes Beware, Scientists Hot on Gene Doping Trail

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 11:27 AM PST

skating

After warning for years that athletes would try to dope their genes, scientists are finding ways to catch them. The tests are still being refined in animals, but will likely berun years from now on samples taken at the upcoming Winter Olympics and stored.

The tests reflect a new approach to doping detection: Rather than targeting specific, easily masked chemicals, they look at system-wide changes in gene expression and protein production.

"Before, drug testers took a toxicological approach," said Olivier Rabin, science director at the World Anti-Doping Agency. "Now we're on much more of a medical and forensic approach."

The International Olympic Committee formally banned gene doping in 2003, when gene therapy and gene-targeting therapeutics were mostly a matter of medical prediction. Since then, they've moved to the edge of medical reality. Most advances are still limited to lab animals, but that hasn't stopped athletes from hoping for an early if unproven edge.

Bodybuilding magazines already carry advertisements for DNA-tweaking drinks and pills. Experts say these are fraudulent, but reputable researchers are routinely contacted by coaches and athletes wondering if their animal treatments can be given to humans.

Three years ago, German track coach Thomas Springstein was busted after unsuccessfully trying to score Repoxygen, an experimental gene therapy drug that boosts red blood cell production, for his runners. At the Olympics in Beijing, an unidentified Chinese doctor offered stem cell injections to a German journalist posing as a swim coach.

"We have no evidence that any athlete bought or used that stuff," said Mark Frankel, an American Association for the Advancement of Science bioethicist who studies gene doping. "But the next big movement forward in terms of cheating is very likely to be in the genetic arena."

myostatin_mouseThe most likely biological targets for cheating are erythropoietin, the protein enhanced by Repoxygen; genes for the production of myostatin and insulin-like growth factor I, which affect muscle production (as in the lower mouse in the photo); and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors, a family of proteins that regulate metabolism and have been touted as providing "exercise in a pill."

For now, none of these boosts can be detected. But all of them are being studied by researchers supported by the World Anti-Doping Agency, who have sponsored dozens of test-developing projects.

Some of the tests are aimed at detecting immediate evidence of doping: leftover fragments of engineered viruses used by gene therapists, telltale proteins, obviously modified DNA sequences, and so on.

But this is difficult. Such evidence is hard to find and degrades quickly in the body. Moreover, even if a first generation of tests are successful, they could be tricked by slight changes to gene-modifying approaches.

Instead, researchers are looking for broader changes that are produced by gene modification and can't be masked. Tweaking insulin-like growth factor, for example, appears to change levels of fatty acid production and body-wide protein expression in ways that can't be masked.

"The concept is that if you suspect doping, you don't look for the drug, but for the effects of the drug on global gene expression and proteomic patterns," said Theodore Friedmann, a University of California, San Diego geneticist who's now combining results from WADA-supported research into statistical models of cheating. "Even if someone makes a chemical change to a drug to make it invisible to testing, they can't wipe out the effects of the drug."

This approach could end up being applicable not only to genetic modification, but to changes produced by traditional performance enhancers, like steroids and growth hormone.

Friedmann cautions that much work remains to be done on these tests, which are still limited to animal studies. But even if they take years to be refined, the tests could be used on biological samples already taken from elite athletes.

"We have to make sure the changes we find aren't caused by gender or nutrition or training, and there are issues with genetic privacy," said Friedmann. "But the samples can be put away for up to eight years. We can go back to them later."

Could even these system-wide tests be duped?

"Anything you do to your body changes your body," said Rabin. "Is there a perfect crime? Many investigators will tell you no."

Images: 1. johnthescone/Flickr 2. Regular (top) and myostatin-tweaked mice/PLoS ONE

See Also:

Brandon Keim's Twitter stream and reportorial outtakes; Wired Science on Twitter. Brandon is currently working on a book about ecological tipping points.

Gene Patents Under Legal Attack

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 09:43 AM PST

dna21

Federal court hearings continued Tuesday on a lawsuit that could transform biotechnology in the United States by eliminating gene patents.

The case hinges around the claims of Utah-based Myriad Genetics on BRCA1 and BRCA2, a pair of genes closely linked to breast and ovarian cancer. Myriad "owns" the genes, and saysits patents make it possible to profit on diagnostic tests. The company argues that if you remove the patents, the tests — indeed, commercial biotechnology as we know it — will vanish.

Acoalition of civil rights, research and women's health groupsis fighting the patents. They argue that Myriad's claims stifle innovation by discouraging researchers from looking at the genes, which are still not fully understood, and say Myriad's monopoly limits women's health choices. More broadly, the claims set a precedent for other gene patents, which now cover about one-fifth of the human genome.

"Allowing patents on genetic material imposes real and severe limits on scientific research, learning and the free flow of information," said Chris Hansen, an attorney with the America Civil Liberties Union, in a press release.

At Tuesday's hearing, defense attorney Brian Poissant insisted that "'women would not even know they had BRCA gene if it weren't discovered' under a system that incentivizes patents," reported GenomeWeb Daily News.

But much of the scientific community rejects Myriad's case. Roughly 150,000 researchers are represented by associations that have filed court briefs supporting the plaintiffs. Among them are the American Medical Association, American Society of Human Genetics and March of Dimes.

In his recent book, The Language of Life: DNA and the Revolution in Personalized Medicine, National Institutes of Health director Francis Collins also argued against broad gene patents.

"The information contained in our shared instruction book is so fundamental, and requires so much further research to understand its utility, that patenting it at the earliest stage is like putting up a whole lot of unnecessary toll booths on the road to discovery," he wrote.

In May, the court rejected Myriad's request that the case be thrown out without a trial. DuringTuesday's hearing, the plaintiffs asked to be declared victorious without a trial. A decision is expected to take several months.

If the court rules against Myriad, patents involving genes and other biological products won't be eliminated altogether. Instead, claims will need to be made on specific types of tests or modifications, rather than the discovery of something that exists in nature. The ACLU likened Myriad's claim to that of someone who patents gold after panning a few nuggets from a stream.

A case memo filed by the plaintiffs called Myriad's prediction of industry doom "pure hyperbole." They cited a 1931 Supreme Court decision that struck down the American Fruit Company's claimed ownership of fresh fruit.

"To be sure, the fruit industry survived," wrote the plaintiffs.

For full documentation of the case, see "Association for Molecular Pathology, et al. v. U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, et al."

Image: ynse/Flickr

See Also:

Brandon Keim's Twitter stream and reportorial outtakes; Wired Science on Twitter. Brandon is currently working on a book about ecological tipping points.

Altitude Causes Weight Loss Without Exercise

Posted: 04 Feb 2010 06:30 AM PST

zugspitze

Just a week at high altitudes can cause sustained weight loss, suggesting that a mountain retreat could be a viable strategy for slimming down.

Overweight, sedentary peoplewho spent aweek atan elevation of 8,700 feet lost weight while eating as much as they wanted and doing no exercise. A month after they came back down, they had kept two-thirds of those pounds off. The results appear in the Feb. 4Obesity.

"What is nice about this paper, is that it clearly demonstrates that there's a lasting effect of decreased caloric intake, that people eat less even a month after they come out of high altitude," said Massachusetts General Hospital anesthesiologist Kay Leissner, who studies high altitude physiology, but was not involved in the study.

Since a 1957 study, scientists have known that animals lose weight at high altitudes. Mountaineers also shed pounds during expeditions to 12,000 feet or more, though the exertion of climbing a mountain clearly played a role.

But the obese aremore likelyto suffer severe altitude sickness, in which low oxygen pressure causes dizziness, nausea and more serious problems like edema or heart attacks, Leissner said.

So a team at Ludwig-Maximilians University in Munich wanted to see if the pounds also melted away with a safer, sedentary stay at somewhat lower altitude.

The scientistsferried 20 overweight, middle-aged men by train and cable car to a research station perched 1,000 feetbelow the peak of Germany's highest mountain, Zugspitze. During the week-long stay, the men could eat and drink as much as they liked and were forbidden from any exercise other than leisurely strolls. The teammeasured the men'sweight, metabolic rate, levels of hunger and satiety hormones before, during, and after their mountain retreat.

After a week up high, the subjects lost an average of3 pounds. A month later, they were still2 pounds lighter. The sceintists' data showed this was likely because they ate about 730 calories less at high altitudes than they did at normal elevations. They may have felt less hungry, in part, because levels of leptin, the satiety hormone, surged during the stay, while grehlin, the hunger hormone, remained unchanged. Their metabolic rate also spiked, meaning they burned more calories than they usually did.

A high-altitude weight loss strategy could be viable, though studies have shown peoples' appetites bounce back after about six months at high elevation, Leissner said. "If you could do intermittent periods for one week, then go down, and then go back up, this might actually be helpful."

One limitation of the study, however,is that it didn't show whether the men lost mostly muscle mass, fat, or water weight,Leissner said.

And the study didn't show that the stay at 8,700 feet was actually safe for the participants, University of Geneva exercise physiologist Bengt Kaysersaid in an e-mail.

New research into why the overweight are prone to heart attacks, diabetes, and other inflammatory diseases, suggest it could be some fat cells grow so rapidly that blood vessel growth can't keep up, and that leads to pockets of oxygen-starved fatty tissue, Kayser said."This causes local inflammation because immune cells get activated."

If that's the case, then shuttling the overweight to even a moderate altitude may worsen inflammation and increase their chances of heart attack or other serious problems.

"So for the moment one has to remain very careful," Kayser said,"and evaluate the question a few more times before migrating all obese Americans to Colorado!"

Image: Zugspitze, Stephan A./flickr

Citation: "Hypobaric Hypoxia Causes Body Weight Reduction in Obese Subjects," Florian J. Lippl, Sonja Neubauer, Susanne Schipfer, Nicole Lichter, Amanda Tufman, Bärbel Otto, and Rainald Fischer. Obesity, 4 February 2010.

See Also:

Thursday, 4 February 2010

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge


How Your Biometrics Can Make Super Bowl Ads Better

Posted: 03 Feb 2010 04:57 PM PST

100_1974-copy

Brian Levine is going to tell me what commercials I like without asking my opinion. He doesn't have to ask. With the biometric toolkit developed by his company, he says that my own subconscious impulses will give it away. My heart rate, the sweatiness of my hands, and how I'm sitting in my seat will give me away.

While he set up an eye-tracker in Wired's offices, I changed into the vest and T-shirt he gave me. I attached two sticky electrodes attached to my breast bone and one beneath my rib cage on the left side of my body. The T-shirt had special holes cut into it, so that the wires could poke through from the electrodes, and plug intothe vest.A small monitor was strapped onto my finger.

beerrobotfinal

COME PARTY, BIOMETRICALLY

We're bringing Innerscope into Wired's offices for a biometric Super Bowl party.During last year's Super Bowl, Innerscope found that Careerbuilder.com's advertisement scored the highest for its engagement rating. PC World later found that the same ad had created the most online buzz. This time around, Innerscope will be measuring ourlocal readers, who'll be strapped up withthe newest version of the firm's biometric tools.We want to see how our readers' biometric responses match up with the commercials they think they liked best and what the world-at-large deems successful.

There are still a few slots open for the Super Bowl party. If you'd like to bring yourself and a friend to Wired HQ to watch the game, drink some beer with Beer Robot, eat some pizza with staffers and have your skin conductance measured, just fill out this form:Wired Biometric Super Bowl Party.

Levine plugged all the wires nowrunning out from my body into a fanny pack with a little PDA in it, which transmitted wirelessly to a laptop. After a little tinkering, my body's basic data appeared on the screen in an endlessly scrolling set of scribbly lines.

Then I sat down in front of a computer screen and watched a series of video clips of cute little babies, Dexter,a video of myself (!), andrandom people dancing at a wedding. The whole time, Ihoped Levine couldn't somehow read an undiagnosed pathology from the the lines on his screen or figure out exactly the sort of advertising that would press my buy button — fears shared by neuroethicists.

The premise of Levine's company, Innerscope, is that running this data through algorithms can tell advertisers which commercials work and which don't. They can quantify your subconscious responses to advertisements without resorting to the messiness of human language.

"We really look at unconscious measures compared to conscious measures," said Innerscope co-founder Carl Marci, director of the Social Neuroscience for the Psychotherapy Research Program atMassachusettsGeneral Hospital. "We know that5 to 25 percent of brain processing is dedicated to conscious processing. The rest is unconscious, and about half of that is emotional processing. You're talking about a massive amount of brain processing."

Some companies in the new neuromarketing field have tried to peer directly into the brain looking for clues to how consumers work. They use fMRI and EEG brain scans and other measures of what's happening in your gray matter.

The field remains "in its infancy," though, according to a 2008 Journal of Consumer Behavior review. It's hard to know how well data captured inside an fMRI machine at a laboratory relates to how your brain wouldfunction at a sports bar, for example.

Innerscope relies on less-fancy techniques, ones that have been proven to correlate with emotional response, but that technological advances have made much easier to deploy on, say, 50 people watching a football game.

What they're looking for is the magnitude of increase in the biomeasurements and how synchronized a bunch of study participants are in experiencing that response.

So, while my test setup was realtively true to reality, it was just a demonstration. Normally, Innerscope uses only aggregate data from a group, not an individual, and the situation is much more tightly circumscribed. (My co-workers wandered in to peer at me in the funny vest and laugh at my fanny pack.)

It's the aggregated reactions that allows Innerscope to separate spikes in biometric response that are positive from those that are negative.

When people love an ad, their biomeasurements go up — and they sustain their attention to it. When people hate an ad, or find it disgusting, Innerscope has found that some of them stop watching or turn away.

What advertisers are afterare the moments that command a coherent positive reaction from the group.

Cassini Gets Life Extension to Explore Saturn Until 2017

Posted: 03 Feb 2010 02:14 PM PST

cassini_saturn_full

NASA gave its Cassini spacecraftmission a 6.5-year life extension to continue exploring Saturn and its moons.

Cassini launched in 1997 and first arrived at Saturn in 2004 after flying by Earth, Venus and Jupiter. It carried the Huygens probe on board, which it sent to the surface of the moon Titan in December 2004. The mission was originally slated to end in 2008, but got its first reprieve with 27 months of additional fundingto study the planet during itsequinox, whenthe sun is directly above the planet's equator, which happens once every 15 Earth years.

The spacecraft has captured some of the most stunning images ever seen of the solar system, and space enthusiasts everywhere, including here at Wired Sciencewere dreading the mission's end. With the Cassini's new lease, those images will continue wowing us into Saturn's summer solstice.

"Cassini has been an adventure of a lifetime, an extraordinary exploration of the most enchanting place in all the solar system," said Carolyn Porco, leader of the Cassini Imaging Team. "It is a very happy day for us, knowing that Cassini lives and the adventure continues."

Cassini has already travelled 2.6 billion miles, and captured 210,000 images, but is in remarkably good shape. In the next seven years, it orbit the planet 155 more times and complete 54 flybys of Titan and 11 flybys of our favorite moon, Enceladus. It will dive between Saturn and its iconic rings, gathering more data onthe planet's magnetosphere.

enceladus_jets"The extension presents a unique opportunity to follow seasonal changes of an outer planet system all the way from its winter to its summer," Bob Pappalardo, Cassini project scientist at JPL, said in a press release. "Some of Cassini's most exciting discoveries still lie ahead."

One of the mysteries Cassini could help solve is the source of the jets emanating from Enceladus. Scientists suspect they are fed by a subsurface ocean that could possibly be a haven for life.

"This extension is important because there is so much still to be learned at Saturn," Bob Mitchell, Cassini program manager at JPL, said in a press release. "The planet is full of secrets, and it doesn't give them up easily."

Images: NASA/JPL/CICLOPS

See Also:

Follow us on Twitter @betsymason and @wiredscience, and on Facebook.

Everywhere in a Flash: The Quantum Physics of Photosynthesis

Posted: 03 Feb 2010 11:40 AM PST

leafveins

By hitting single molecules with quadrillionth-of-a-second laser pulses, scientists have revealed the quantum physics underlying photosynthesis, the process used by plants and bacteria to convert light into energy, at efficiencies unapproached by human engineers.

The quantum wizardry appears to occur in each of a photosynthetic cell's millions of antenna proteins. These route energy from electrons spinning in photon-sensitive molecules to nearby reaction-center proteins, which convert it to cell-driving charges.

Almost no energy is lost in between. That's because it exists in multiple places at once, and always finds the shortest path.

pc645-view4"The analogy I like is if you have three ways of driving home through rush hour traffic. On any given day, you take only one. You don't know if the other routes would be quicker or slower. But in quantum mechanics, you can take all three of these routes simultaneously. You don't specify where you are until you arrive, so you always choose the quickest route," said Greg Scholes, a University of Toronto biophysicist.

Scholes' findings, published Wednesday in Nature, are the strongest evidence yet for coherence — the technical name for multiple-state existence —in photosynthesis.

Two years ago, researchers led by then-University of California at Berkeley chemist Greg Engel found coherence in the antenna proteins of green sulfur bacteria. But their observations were made at temperatures below minus 300 degrees Fahrenheit, useful for slowing ultrafast quantum activities but leaving open the question of whether coherence operates in everyday conditions.

The Nature findings, made at room temperature in common marine algae, show that it does. Moreover, similar results from an experiment on another, simpler light-harvesting structure, announced by Engels' group last Thursday on the pre-publication online arXiv, suggest that photosynthetic coherence is routine.

The findings are wondrous in themselves, adding a new dimension to something taught — incompletely, it now seems — to every high school biology student. They also have important implications for designers of solar cells and computers, who could benefit from quantum physics conducted in nonfrigid conditions.

"There's every reason to believe this is a general phenomenon," said Engel, now at the University of Chicago. He called Scholes' finding "an extraordinary result" that "shows us a new way to use quantum effects at high temperatures."

Scholes' team experimented on an antenna protein called PC645, already imaged at the atomic scale in earlier studies. That precise characterization allowed them to target molecules with laser pulses lasting for one-quadrillionth of a second, or just long enough to set single electrons spinning.

quantumphotographBy analyzing changes to a laser beam sent through the protein immediately afterwards, the researchers were able to extrapolate what was happening inside — an ultra-high-tech version of shadows on a screen. They found that energy patterns in distant molecules fluctuated in ways that betrayed a connection to each other, something only possible through quantum coherence.

"It's the same as when you hit two tuning forks at the same time, and hear a low-pitched oscillation in the background. That's the interference of sound waves from the forks. That's exactly what we see," said Scholes.

According to Scholes, the physics of photosynthetic proteins will be further studied and used to improve solar cell design. Engels suggested their use in long-promised but still-unworkable quantum computing. "This allows us to think about photosynthesis as non-unitary quantum computation," he said.

Quantum-physical processes have been observed elsewhere in the biological realm, most notably in compass cells that allow birds to navigateby Earth's geomagnetic fields. Researchers have also proposed roles for quantum physics in the animal sense of smell and even in the brain. Engels predicts the emergence of an entire field of quantum biology.

"There are going to be some surprises," said Scholes. "Who knows what else there is to discover?"

Images: 1. Bùi Linh Ngân/Flickr
2. Antenna protein: Light-harvesting molecules are red./Greg Scholes
3. Graph of energy wave interference inside the antenna protein/
Nature

See Also:

Citations: "Coherently wired light-harvesting in photosynthetic marine algae at ambient temperature." By Elisabetta Collini, Cathy Y. Wong, Krystyna E. Wilk, Paul M. G. Curmi, Paul Brumer & Gregory D. Scholes. Nature, Vol. 463 No. 7281, Feb. 4, 2010.

"Long-lived quantum coherence in photosynthetic complexes at physiological temperature." By Gitt Panitchayangkoon, Dugan Hayes, Kelly A. Fransted, Justin R. Caram, Elad Harel, Jianzhong Wen, Robert E. Blankenship, Gregory S. Engel. arXiv, Jan. 28, 2010.

Brandon Keim's Twitter stream and reportorial outtakes; Wired Science on Twitter. Brandon is currently working on a book about ecological tipping points.

Wednesday, 3 February 2010

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge


Telescope Finds Galaxy’s Most Massive Star Yet

Posted: 03 Feb 2010 03:00 AM PST

stellar-nursery-ngc-3603

This glowing stellar nursery is home to the most massive star yet found in the Milky Way galaxy.

Captured by theEuropean Southern Observatory's 27 f00t-diameter Very Large Telescope at Cerro Paranal, Chile, the imageabove combinesdatataken with violet, red, and infrared filters.

The nebula, NGC 3603, is surrounded by a cloud of glowing gas and dust in the Carina spiral arm of the Milky Way galaxy, about 20,000 light-years from Earth in the Carina constellation. This active star-forming region is one of the brightest and most compact star clusters in our galaxy. The cosmic nursery is teeming with thousands of young, massive suns, including several blue supergiants and three massive Wolf-Rayet stars. These brilliant stars eject huge amounts of mass before blazing out in spectacular supernova explosions.The most massive star in the cluster is 116 times as massive as the Sun.

The photo below shows the broader area around the NGC 3603 nebula.

ngc_3603_vicinity

Images: ESO

See Also:

Follow us on Twitter @tiaghose and @wiredscience, and on Facebook.

New Look at Big Bang Radiation Refines Age of Universe

Posted: 03 Feb 2010 12:41 AM PST

wmap

Six papers posted online present new satellite snapshots of the earliest light in the universe. By analyzing these images, cosmologists have made the most accurate determination of the age of the cosmos, have directly detected primordial helium gas for the first time and have discovered a key signature of inflation, the leading model of how the cosmos came to be.

sciencenewsThe analysis, based on the first seven years of data taken by NASA's Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe, also provides new evidence that the mysterious entity revving up the expansion of the universe resembles Einstein's cosmological constant, a factor he inserted but later removed from his theory of general relativity. In addition, the data reveal that theorists don't have the right model to explain the hot gas that surrounds massive clusters of galaxies.

Researchers studying the light, which was generated at the birth of the cosmos but was seen by the satellite as it appeared when it first escaped into space about 400,000 years later, unveiled the findings in six papers posted online January 26. The ancient light, known as the cosmic microwave background, is peppered with hot and cold spots, signs of the tiny primordial lumps from which galaxies grew.

To calculate the age of the universe, scientists including David Spergel of Princeton University and Charles Bennett of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore compared the size of those hot and cold spots today with the size of the spots when the radiation was first released into space. Using data from WMAP along with studies of distant supernovas and other phenomena, the team finds that the universe is 13.75 billion years old, give or take 0.11 billion. (By comparison, the team's previous calculation, which used the same method but included only five years of satellite observations, had pegged the universe at 13.73 billion years, plus or minus 0.12 billion.)

Data from the WMAP satellite supports the idea that the early universe inflated rapidly, Bennett says. Inflation theory, which posits that the universe ballooned from subatomic scale to the size of a soccer ball during its first 10-33 seconds, has had great success in explaining the structure of the universe. According to the theory, fluctuations in the intensity of microwave background radiation over larger spatial scales should be slightly bigger than those on smaller scales. The satellite, which was launched in 2001 and will make its last observations this fall, has confirmed that behavior.

"This is a really strong endorsement for the theory," says Scott Dodelson of the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory in Batavia, Ill.

The standard model of cosmology — replete with inflation, invisible material known as dark matter and something called dark energy, which is believed to accelerate cosmic expansion—"is a wild idea," admits Bennett. But with the newest analysis of the satellite observations "we have confronted the model against the data in a substantially new way… and this picture is holding up very well."

By using the satellite data to measure the speed of acoustic oscillations — the cosmic equivalent of sound waves — astronomers have confirmed that the early universe forged helium in addition to hydrogen, just as the Big Bang theory has long predicted. Previous studies were based on the amount of helium present in the cosmos' oldest stars rather than a direct detection of the gas in the early universe.

"This opens up a new window for measuring primordial helium," Dodelson comments.

The detection "is not a surprise, but it's nice to have confirmation," Spergel says.

Researchers also analyzed the satellite data to discern the diversity of neutral elementary particles called neutrinos in the universe. Physicists know of three types—the electron neutrino, the muon neutrino and the tau neutrino. But the current data would be consistent with the existence of either three or four types. The analysis of an additional two years of observations from the satellite may settle whether a fourth type exists, says Bennett.

In a separate finding, WMAP detected the abundance of microwave background photons in the vicinity of galaxy clusters. Here, the satellite has come into conflict with theory. Energetic electrons associated with galaxy clusters are known to interact with some of the microwave background photons, kicking the photons to higher energies than the probe can detect. As a result, the probe ought to record fewer microwave-energy photons in the vicinity of clusters.

The probe indeed records a deficit, but it's only about half the amount predicted by galaxy cluster theory. The South Pole Telescope, a ground-based experiment that also studies the cosmic microwave background, also finds a lower-than-expected deficit. The mismatch suggests that theorists will have to revise their understanding of galaxy clusters, says Bennett.

Image: NASA/WMAP Science Team

See Also:

Follow us on Twitter @betsymason and @wiredscience, and on Facebook.

Video: Solar Eclipse Seen From Space

Posted: 02 Feb 2010 12:03 PM PST

A European satellite launched late last year has returned a new animation of the annular solar eclipse that occurred on Jan. 15.

The images returned by the Proba 2 mission are the first of their kind and part of the first set of data released by the European Space Agency. A similar, more robust sun-observing platform, the Solar and Helisopheric Observatory, is unable to see eclipses.

The images that compose the animation were taken about one minute apart. The eclipse was viewable from Earth for more than 11 minutes.

The new satellite is just beginning its lifespan and was largely conceived as a test of new hardware more than a scientific mission. But the small satellite — a bit smaller than a cubic meter (or about 35 cubic feet) — will also deliver this kind of novel view of the sun.


Via Space.com

See Also:

WiSci 2.0: Alexis Madrigal's Twitter, Google Reader feed, and green tech history research site; Wired Science on Twitter and Facebook.

The Potential for a 40-MPH Man

Posted: 02 Feb 2010 11:15 AM PST

2768827206_d6e65eea44_b1

The human frame isbuilt tohandle running speeds up to 40 miles per hour, scientists say. The only limiting factor is not how much brute force is required to push off the ground as previously thought, but how fast our muscle fibers can contract to ramp up that force.

"If you just find a way to rev up those contractile fibers for the muscle, then everything else from human biology and gait would allow us to be that fast," said physiologist Peter Weyand of Southern Methodist University, lead author ofa study published Jan. 21 in the Journal of Applied Physiology.

For years, scientists have sought to find the physiological limits of human running speed, and to understand why even the world's fastest man, Jamaican sprinter Usain Bolt,can't outrun some animals.Bolt'stop speed of 27.3 miles an hour can't match that of horses, dogs or the hopping kangaroo, whichcan travel at35 miles per hour.

"The current best guess as to why we can't run any faster is it's something to do with the maximum force that our legs can impose or experience," said zoologist Jim Usherwood of the Royal Veterinary College in London.

Earlier studies found that elite sprinters and average sprinters outperformed their mediocre counterparts in two ways: They were able to push harder on the ground in relation to their body's weight with each step, and they were able to do that in a shorter period of time. For instance, Bolt generates almost a ton of force in his leg in the less than a tenth of a second his foot is on the ground, Weyand said. The force you can generate before leaving the ground is a function of the rate at which muscle fibers generate force multiplied by the time the foot touches the ground.

But the previouswork didn't reveal whether it is the amount of time the foot is pushing on the ground or the maximum force the leg is capable of that limits human running speed.

To get to the bottom of the human speed limit, Weyand and colleaguesstudied seven athletes, from an all-American track star to a dancer, as theysprinted forward, hopped on one leg and ran backwards on a turbo treadmill outfitted with force sensors. The team measured speed, upward force as each foot struck the ground, and the time the foot spent on the ground between strides.

The one-legged hop generated much more force in the leg than sprinting did, mainly because a runner has to jump higher in order to land on the same foot. Because the athlete's legs were capable of generating more force than when they run, the amount of force can't bewhat's limiting the runners' forward speeds.

The backwards run showed that the contact time with the groundwas almost identical duringeach athlete'sfastest forward and backward runs, suggesting contact time was the limiting factor keeping them from going faster in any direction.

This suggests the only way to increase speed is to generate force more quickly during the limited time the foot is on the ground. The key todoing thisis increasing how fast the muscle fibers can contract to produce force. If that were possible, Weyand's team calculated that humans could theoretically runas fast as35 or 40 milesper hour, based on our gait and the maximum forces our muscles can generate.

One option would be to increase the proportion of ultrafast 2X type muscle fiber, one of three types of mammalian muscle fibers. Studies have shown that athletes can slightly increase their 2X fibers by training intensely and then taking a break for a few weeks, he said.

But even if a training regimen could be designed to quicken our muscle fibers enough to achieve our fullrunning potential, animals like cheetahs and dogs will still leave us in the dust. These animals outrun us not because they have faster muscle fibers, but because of their unique gait, the study concluded.

"When their forelimbs hit the ground, their whole spine just bends like crazy," Weyand said. That allows them to keep their feet on the ground longer, building up force, while still maintaining a forward momentum.

Usherwood agreed with the basic conclusion of the paper, that "actually we can produce lots more force if we do all sorts of odd things like hopping on one leg. Just the biggest force you can cope with with doesn't determine how fast you sprint."

But he's skeptical about the potential for a 40-mile-an-hour man. 'The authors are playing a fun game, of 'what if,'" he said. But even if our muscle fibers were faster, other limitations, like how fast we can swing our legs, are sure to kick in, he said.

Photo of Usain Bolt: antonhazelwinkel/Flickr

Citation: "The biological limits to running speed are imposed from the ground up" Peter G. Weyand, Rosalind F. Sandell, Danille Naomi Leoni Prime, and Matthew W. Bundle, Journal of Applied Physiology, Jan. 21, 2010

See Also:

Follow us on Twitter @tiaghose and @wiredscience, and on Facebook.

Plant-Virus Tricks Teach Evolutionary Pest Management

Posted: 02 Feb 2010 11:03 AM PST

cmv

The cucumber mosaic virus uses a clever subterfuge to spread — it changes the way host plants smell. It's a neat example of evolutionary exploitation and a lesson in how managing the dynamics of evolution may help control pests.

The virus causes plants to produce aphid-attracting odors. At the same time, it makes the plant sickly. Bugs arrive at the plant, find it a poor home, and quickly depart. But their brief landing is sufficient to pick up the virus, which they carry to other, healthier plants.

"The mode of transmission is a major factor influencing the effects of pathogens on plants," said Mark Mescher, a Penn State University chemical ecologist. "In human and agricultural systems, it's time to start moving beyond thinking how to directly manage a pest or pathogen, and towards managing their evolution."

Mescher, who describes the transmission of the cucumber mosaic virus in a study published Monday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, specializes in the chemical cues plants use to communicate. These are surprisingly sophisticated: His earlier work involved predator-attracting chemicals released by plants when eaten by grazers.

In the PNAS study, Mescher's team showed how aphids — tiny, ubiquitous insects that feed on plant sap —preferred infected squash plants, though they left shortly after landing. This is likely because chemical cue production was doubled in infected plants: Though withered and sickly, they smelled large and healthy from a distance.

The findings add to a growing body of research on odor-changing diseases. Trees afflicted by Dutch Elm disease produce insect-attracting chemicals, as does wheat infected with rust fungi. In the animal world, research has found that hamsters infected with Leishmaniasis, a flesh-eating disease common in much of the developing world, attract disease-spreading sandflies. Another study found that mosquitoes appear drawn by smell to people with malaria, though the disease is as dangerous to them as to us.

Studies like these hint at little-appreciated disease dynamics, in which pathogens have evolved subtle ways of spreading themselves, with their ostensible targets just one stop in a network of transmission. They may also suggest new targets for controlling diseases that have evaded standard treatments.

Mescher, who is now studying malarial odor changes, said that such interventions represent a comprehensive approach to disease. "We need to think of what the transmission dynamics are that lead to more harmful pathogens, and what dynamics lead to less harmful pathogens," he said.

Image: (A) A healthy cucumber plant; (B) an infected plant; (C) aphids; )D) aphids./PNAS

See Also:

Citation: "Deceptive chemical signals induced by a plant virus attract insect vectors to inferior hosts." By Kerry E. Mauck, Consuelo M. DeMoraes, and Mark C. Mescher. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 107 No. 5, February 2, 2010.

Brandon Keim's Twitter stream and reportorial outtakes; Wired Science on Twitter. Brandon is currently working on a book about ecological tipping points.

Hubble Spots First Potential Asteroid Collision

Posted: 02 Feb 2010 10:10 AM PST

nasa-x

The X marks the spot of a suspected head-on collision between two asteroids imaged by the Hubble Space Telescope's new-and-improved Wide Field Camera.

If it's confirmed by further observations, it would be the first time that scientists have detected the interplanetary collision between objects in the asteroid belt, though they believe that such occurrences are common.

The complex structure of the debris is what makes astronomers think they may be seeing something new around the sun. The main nucleus of the object, P/2010 A2, is actually located outside its dust halo, something that's never been seen in a comet-like object before.

"The filamentary appearance of P/2010 A2 is different from anything seen in Hubble images of normal comets, consistent with the action of a different process," said David Jewitt, an astronomer at the University of California Los Angeles, in a press release.

They hypothesize that the filaments are made up of dust and gravel created by a high speed impact that could have occurred at 11,000 miles per hour.

"If this interpretation is correct, two small and previously unknown asteroids recently collided, creating a shower of debris that is being swept back into a tail from the collision site by the pressure of sunlight," Jewitt said.

Image: NASA, ESA, and D. Jewitt. XL version available.

See Also:

WiSci 2.0: Alexis Madrigal's Twitter, Google Reader feed, and green tech history research site; Wired Science on Twitter and Facebook.

NASA Radar Jet Acquires First 3-D Image of Haiti

Posted: 02 Feb 2010 10:05 AM PST

haiti_uavsar
NASA's radar-equipped jet has returned its first 3-D image of Port-au-Prince, Haiti. This false-color image clearly shows the Enriquillo-Plantain Garden Fault extending east of the city.

The image supports a Jan. 21 U.S. Geological Survey report that suggested the section of the fault (indicated by the black arrow above) nearest to Port-au-Prince(yellow arrow)did notslip significantly in the magnitude 7 Jan. 12 earthquake.

The new image, taken by JPL's Uninhabited Aerial Vehicle Synthetic Aperture Radar attached to a modified Gulfstream III jet, shows that the ground rupture moved westward from the epicenter. The section of the fault in the image did not rupture, a situation that increases the risk of another significant earthquake in the future.

The USGS report noted that two large earthquakesstruck the area in1751 and 1770, most likely on the Enriquillo fault, which runs from western Haiti into the Dominican Republic. If a similar succession occurs in the coming years, it could be devastating, particularly if Haiti is not rebuilt with this risk in mind.

The UAVSAR will be flown over the area repeatedlyin the coming days. Data from the first flights will be compared to later flights to measure minute changes in the landscape that could reveal how quickly the earth on either side of the fault is moving and building up stress. This will help scientists assess the risk of more quakes.

The colors in the image, which shows a swath of about 12.5 miles,are the result of three different radar polarizations that make vegetation appear green, water appear blue and urban areas look reddish.

After imaging Haiti, the jet will head to Central America on a previously scheduled trip to study volcanoes, forests and Mayan ruins. NASA says the UAVSAR will eventually beadapted to flyin unmanned aircraft such as the Northrop Grumman Global Hawk.

Image: NASA/JPL

See Also:

Follow us on Twitter @betsymason and @wiredscience, and on Facebook.

Tuesday, 2 February 2010

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge

Johnald's Fantastical Daily Link Splurge


Charting the Winners and Losers in Obama’s Science Budget

Posted: 01 Feb 2010 12:32 PM PST

proposed-changes

PresidentObama's administration revealed its new budget Monday, and it increases funding for nearly all areas of science.

The largestraise went to the National Institutes of Health, which added $1 billion dollars toan already hefty budget. With the boost, the NIH would receive $32.1 billion in total funding. Only the Centers for Disease Control would receive less money thanlast year, although the cut is small. NASA, the Department of Energy's Office of Science, and the National Science Foundation, as well as smaller research efforts at the National Institute for Standards and Technology and Department of Agriculture, would also get bumps.

Of course, Obama's current budget is just a proposal. It still has to make it through Congress and some of his moves — like scrapping the Constellation program mission to the moon — could face heavy opposition.

If approved, the increases would come in addition to thefunding for science handed out by the stimulus package, which the Obama administration has often referred to as the "largest single boost in scientific research in history."

See Also:

WiSci 2.0: Alexis Madrigal's Twitter, Google Reader feed, and green tech history research site; Wired Science on Twitter and Facebook.

The Lost Turkeys of the New World

Posted: 01 Feb 2010 12:00 PM PST

turkeybowl-s

Modern dinner-table turkeys are descended from birds domesticated 3,000 years ago by the Aztecs. But they weren't the only turkey tamers: Indigenous inhabitants of what became the southwestern United States had their own prize breeds, now lost to posterity.

Until now, it was assumed that all domesticated turkeys could be traced to the Aztec-bred lineage. However, a genetic analysis of bones and droppings at 38 archaeological sites in the southwestern U.S. shows that the birds there belonged to a distinctly different subspecies.

turkeymapAccording to the findings, published Monday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, that single turkey breed prevailed for more than a millennia among the southwest's natives. But even as turkey husbandry reached its height among the Anasazi and Mogollon and Salado, the local birds' doom had already begun.

In the 15th century, Spanish Conquistadors took Aztec turkeys back to Europe. The birds proved popular, and were bred with local subspecies before being reintroduced to North America by colonial settlers in the 17th century. The settlers' birds were carried westward as part of the same historical wave that obliterated native southwestern culture.

The colonial turkeys ultimately became, in highly modified form, the industrial gargantuans of Thanksgiving fame. As for native southwestern turkeys, a handful of genes from a few escapees linger in existing wild birds, but the originals are gone.

"We have no genetic evidence that these breeds survived into the present day," said study co-author Dongya Yang, a Simon Fraser University archaeologist. But historically-inclined foodies may have better luck finding pure-blooded descendants of the Aztec birds. "It is quite likely that the indigenous Mesoamerican turkey breeds still survive in rural Mexico," said Yang.

Images: 1. Detail from Mimbres pottery bowl, circa AD 1000-1200, from Eric Kaldahl/Amerind Foundation 2. A network representation of the genetic relationships between North American wild and domestic turkeys/PNAS. Southwestern turkeys are the gray circles; modern commercial turkeys occupy the tiny, mostly-white mHap1 circle on the left.

See Also:

Citation: "Ancient mitochondrial DNAanalysis reveals complexity of indigenous North American turkey domestication." By Camilla F. Speller, Brian M. Kemp, Scott D. Wyatt, Cara Monroe, William D. Lipe, Ursula M. Arndt, and Dongya Y. Yanga. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 107 No. 5, February 2, 2010.

Brandon Keim's Twitter stream and reportorial outtakes; Wired Science on Twitter. Brandon is currently working on a book about ecological tipping points.

Obama Gives NASA More Money, Cuts Manned Trip to Moon

Posted: 01 Feb 2010 11:02 AM PST

163602main_aresv_liftoff_hires

The Obama administrationhas officially decided toend the Constellation mission back to the moon, although the replacement plan faces a tough route through Congress.

The new plan, which had been rumored for months, was announced today with the release of the Obama administration's NASA budget request, which despite the axing of the moon plan delivers a $6 billion funding increase over the next five years.

"NASA's Constellation program — based largely on existing technologies — was begun to realize a vision of returning astronauts back to the Moon by 2020. However, the program was over budget, behind schedule, and lacking in innovation due to a failure to invest in critical new technologies," the budget summary concluded. "Using a broad range of criteria, an independent review panel determined that even if fully funded, NASA's program to repeat many of the achievements of the Apollo era, 50 years later, was the least attractive approach to space exploration as compared to potential alternatives."

As anticipated, the independent Augustine Panel's work was used as the basis for the new NASA direction. Though the blue-ribbon panel did not officially take a position on which future plan made the most sense for NASA, statements made by members and the tone of their report made it clear that a continuation of the Constellation mission was not the group's favored choice.

Constellation had been heavily criticized since it was unveiled in 2005 by President George W. Bush. Even before the plan was announced, some scientists pointed out that manned exploration has drawbacks, such as high costs, extreme safety requirements, and humans' biological sensitivity to radiation. Scientists such as Ronald Arkin of the Mobile Robot Laboratory asked whether robots could do exploration better. The high-profile success of the Mars Rovers, Cassini, and Mars Phoenix mission suggested that robotic exploration was viable, at the very least.

Even among those who supported blasting humans out of the atmosphere, the details of the Constellation program were subject to attack. Many criticized the Bush administration for not providing enough money to back its grand Vision for Space Exploration.

In commenting on the Augustine report, David Mindell, a science and technology historian at MIT, called it, approvingly, "an utter rejection of the Bush plan because it's unfundable, unbuildable and dangerous. "

NASA administrator Charles Bolden made measured statements, ultimately noting that regardless of Constellation's merits, it was not going to put humans back on the moon as envisioned.

"We were not on a sustainable path back to the moon's surface," Bolden said.

The Obama administration's budget also knocked the Constellation program for siphoning money "away from other NASA programs, including robotic space exploration, science, and Earth observations."

While Bolden painted a sweeping portrait of positive change, several key congressional representatives are spoiling for a fight over the loss of programs in their districts.

Richard Shelby, a Republican from Alabama, whose district includes the Marshall Space Flight Center, lashed out against the administration plan.

"The President's proposed NASA budget begins the death march for the future of U.S. human space flight. The cancellation of the Constellation program and the end of human space flight does represent change — but it is certainly not the change I believe in," Shelby wrote in a statement. "Congress cannot and will not sit back and watch the reckless abandonment of sound principles, a proven track record, a steady path to success, and the destruction of our human space flight program."

Shelby harped on the need for safety in manned missions and held that commercial companies could not provide the low levels of risk that NASA could. Bolden, though, in his statements to the press, provided a personal guarantee that he'd protect astronaut lives.

"I flew on the space shuttle four times," he said. "I lost friends in two space shuttle tragedies, so I give you my word that these vehicles will be safe."

Predictably, commercial spaceflight companies were ecstatic at the news.

"Working with NASA, the industry can develop the capabilities to safely launch U.S. astronauts just as commercial spaceflight providers are already trusted by the U.S. government right now to launch multi-billion dollar military satellites, upon which the security of our nation and lives of our troops overseas depend," wrote Bretton Alexander, president of the Commercial Spaceflight Federation, in a prepared statement. "Investing $6 billion will fund a full program of multiple winners for commercial crew, so that robust competition in the marketplace can reduce costs and generate innovation."

See Also:

WiSci 2.0: Alexis Madrigal's Twitter, Google Reader feed, and green tech history research site; Wired Science on Twitter and Facebook.